The proud mom shares her three daughters — Wyatt, Elliotte and Bennett — with husband Jason Kelce

Jason Kelce and Kylie Kelce’s daughter traveled under the sea for her 4th birthday!

On Sunday, the mom of three, 31, shared a few photos from daughter Wyatt’s mermaid-themed birthday party, which included vibrant decor such as teal, purple, pink and orange balloons. Kylie reshared a photo of her daughter on her Instagram Story as she played in a giant bubble house, surrounded by multicolored balloons.

“Wouldn’t be a proper mermaid party without a BUBBLE!” read the text on the photo, as Kylie added, “Peep Wyatt 👀 She was in love.”

Another picture showed a giant backdrop of a mermaid, made by Venus & High Volt Co., with the words, “Wyatt Turns Four,” written across the top.

Jason, 35, was also seen at Wyatt’s party, smiling in a family photo with his three daughters and wife. The Philadelphia Eagles center held daughter Bennett Llewellyn, 7 months, and stood next to Kylie, who held Wyatt and daughter Elliotte Ray, 2. Both the photos and the balloons were done by Charming Garlands.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Jason Kelce and Kylie Kelce’s daughters at Wyatt’s birthday party.@CHARMINGGARLANDS

 Kylie Kelce Reveals Hefty Price She and Jason Kelce Paid for Daughters’ Super Bowl Tickets

In another photo, the couple’s two older daughters pose together in front of the mermaid poster, with Wyatt draping one arm around her sister Elliotte.

The football player was later seen adorably playing with daughter Wyatt in a giant balloon house, flipping her around and playing with floating balloons as she tugged at his beard.

Kylie later shared a few pictures from the party on her Instagram, taking a minute to honor her oldest daughter. “Happy Fourth Birthday to our sassy, opinionated, sweet, empathetic, and intelligent Wyatt!” she wrote.

Jason Kelce and Kylie Kelce’s family at daughter Wyatt’s birthday party. 

In February, the mom of three spoke to PEOPLE about what she loves most about Jason as a girl dad. “I don’t think in his life, Jason ever assumed that he would be the father of three daughters,” Kylie told PEOPLE at the time.

“He would always be like, ‘No, no, we’ll get a boy. We’ll get a boy.’ And I’m like, ‘You got to stop challenging the universe. Stop saying it because you’re the universe is like, ‘Yeah, okay,’ ” she chuckled.

“I used to tell him before we had our first daughter, she’s gonna have you wrapped around her finger. He said, ‘I’m not gonna spoil her!’ And I’m like, ‘I don’t think you understand.'”

Play video